Milk · Mother and young
Are calves separated from their mothers?
In nature a calf drinks from its mother for 9 to 10 months. Here it is often only hours. Furthest along: Zeit zu zweit (cow and calf together). Weakest: 5 standards, among them Conventional and Pasture milk without a label.
Why it is like this
A cow only gives milk after she has calved. Cows build a strong bond with the calf after short contact, and a later separation stresses them, says the Thünen Institute. Separation within a day is usual, often after a few hours. The calf then gets milk replacer or milk from a bucket or feeding machine. In 2020 Stiftung Warentest counted more than 80 farms where calves stay with the cows.
What the labels say
| Standard | Level |
|---|---|
| Conventional | 1 Only briefly. It may be separated right after birth |
| Pasture milk without a label | 1 Only briefly. It may be separated right after birth |
| Pro Weideland | 1 Only briefly. It may be separated right after birth |
| Tierschutzbund entry level | no fixed rule |
| Tierschutzbund premium level | no fixed rule |
| Organic (EU) | 1 Only briefly. It may be separated right after birth |
| Biopark | 1-3 level 1 guaranteed (Only briefly. It may be separated right after birth); up to level 3 depending on the farm |
| Gäa | 1-3 level 1 guaranteed (Only briefly. It may be separated right after birth); up to level 3 depending on the farm |
| Bioland | 1-3 level 1 guaranteed (Only briefly. It may be separated right after birth); up to level 3 depending on the farm |
| Naturland | 1-3 level 1 guaranteed (Only briefly. It may be separated right after birth); up to level 3 depending on the farm |
| Demeter | 1 Only briefly. It may be separated right after birth |
| Zeit zu zweit (cow and calf together) | 2-3 level 2 guaranteed (A few weeks); up to level 3 depending on the farm |
How we read the levels
- Only briefly. It may be separated right after birth.
- A few weeks.
- Several months.
- Until the two part of their own accord.
Level 1: Only briefly. It may be separated right after birth.
Applies to: Conventional, Pasture milk without a label, Pro Weideland, Organic (EU), Biopark, Gäa, Bioland, Naturland and Demeter
The calf is separated from its mother within a day, often after a few hours. It then gets milk replacer, or milk from a bucket or automatic feeder. This is the case for conventional milk, pasture milk without a label, EU organic and Demeter.
After the separation, the cow calls for a few hours up to a whole day. The calves spend the first weeks alone in pens, and single housing is allowed until week 8 of life. Male calves are usually sold after about 14 days. At Bioland and Gäa, the calf should stay with its mother for at least one day and get natural milk for at least 90 days, preferably mother's milk. That does not have to mean it stays with her.
Level 2: A few weeks.
Applies to: Zeit zu zweit (cow and calf together)
Possible on some farms, not guaranteed: Biopark, Gäa, Bioland and Naturland
The calf stays with its mother or a nurse cow for at least four weeks. The "Zeit zu zweit" label and some associations start here.
With Zeit zu zweit (Demeter and ProVieh), the calf drinks from its mother or from a nurse cow. The animals meet at least twice a day. We did not open a criteria sheet for this ourselves (UNSICHER). In Germany, according to Stiftung Warentest 2020, there are more than 80 farms with cow-calf contact, which is less than 1 percent of all dairy farms (ProVieh, read only through a search).
Level 3: Several months.
Possible on some farms, not guaranteed: Biopark, Gäa, Bioland, Naturland and Zeit zu zweit (cow and calf together)
The calf stays with the cows for several months, at least three months. It drinks from its mother at any time and lives in the herd.
This is how the De Öko Melkburen work: six Bioland and Demeter farms in Schleswig-Holstein, since 2014. The cows are still milked, but the farms sell less milk. A litre costs 1.79 to 2.29 euros. The IG Kalb und Kuh requires at least 90 days from its member farms. According to the Thünen Institute, calves take in antibodies through mother's milk, fall ill less often and grow faster. We did not find what happens afterwards to the bull calves of these farms (UNSICHER).
What stays open
There is no rule on this (Pro Weideland, Tierschutzbund). The usual case is that the calf is separated from its mother within 24 hours, often after a few hours.
Videos
This is why cows and calves die so youngQuarks, 8 minExplains why dairy cows and calves often die early and how that relates to milk production.
For more animal welfare: cow-bound calf rearingUnser Land, 7 minA farm keeps calves with their mothers instead of separating them right after birth.
A rarity: conventional dairy farm with foster-cow keepingUnser Land, 5 minOn a conventional dairy farm, nurse cows raise the newborn calves.
Further reading
- Utopia: Parental leave for cows, De Öko Melkburen (in German) (Article)
- Stiftung Warentest: When mother cows have parental leave (in German) (Article)
- IG Kalb und Kuh (cow-bound calf rearing): guidelines and member farms (in German) (Association page)
- ARTE Re: From discarded calf to saviour of the Alps (31 min.) (in German) (Video)
- Vier Pfoten: Alternative dairy cow keeping (cow and calf together, nurse cow) (in German) (Article)
Sources
- thuenen.de
- test.de
- Albert Schweitzer Stiftung: Milchkühe
- Albert Schweitzer Stiftung: Mastkälber
- Bioland standards 03/2026
- Zeit zu zweit (Utopia)
- ProVieh: fact sheet dairy cows 2023 (animal welfare organisation)
- Biopark producer standards 01/2022
- Gäa standards 03/2025
- Naturland production standards 05/2026
- Demeter standards 2026
- Thünen Institute: cow and calf in contact
- Stiftung Warentest 2020: when mother cows get parental leave
- Albert Schweitzer Stiftung: Mastrinder
- Animal welfare label (Tierschutzlabel), consumer advice centre 11/2026
- Everything on Milk
- How long do dairy cows live?
- How much room do dairy cows have?
- What do dairy cows lie on?
- Do dairy cows get to graze on pasture?
- Are dairy cows' horns removed?
- How long are cows transported?
- How are dairy cows slaughtered?
- Label: Conventional farming
- Label: Pasture milk without a label
- Label: Pro Weideland
- Label: EU organic
- Label: Biopark
- Label: Gäa
- Label: Bioland
- Label: Naturland
- Label: Demeter
- Label: Zeit zu zweit (cow and calf together)
- Demeter vs Bioland: Milk
- Bioland vs Naturland: Milk
- Demeter vs Naturland: Milk
- Bioland vs EU organic: Milk